A narrow, shadowy stairwell leads toward a warm-lit wooden door; worn steps and towering dark walls create a stark, eerie mood.

The risk register won’t make the decision for you

Boards spend considerable time on risk, but is that attention influencing decisions? The IoD Risk Survey 2026 reveals where gaps remain.

author
Judene Edgar, Principal Governance Advisor, IoD
date
30 Oct 2026

The risk register has been reviewed, emerging threats discussed and management’s mitigation plans acknowledged. The board is satisfied that risks are being monitored.

But what has changed as a result? Has an investment been reconsidered? Has the board tested whether the organisation could absorb a major disruption? Does it understand what would trigger a different decision?

The Institute of Directors’ Risk Survey 2026 provides insight into how boards are responding to an interconnected risk environment.

Risk is firmly established on board agendas, yet the extent to which that attention translates into deeper analysis, financial understanding and decision-making varies considerably. 

When risk changes the business

Geopolitical risk is already influencing commercial decisions. Nearly half (46%) of respondents had adjusted investment timing or capital allocation in response to geopolitical or geoeconomic risk. Another 43.6% had reviewed market or customer concentration, while 39.4% had undertaken scenario analysis.

These decisions affect where organisations invest, which markets they pursue and how much flexibility they retain.

Geopolitical risk can reach organisations through fuel prices, freight costs, trade restrictions and changing customer behaviour. Its effects rarely arrive neatly separated into the categories used in a risk register.

A supply chain disruption may become a liquidity problem. A climate event may affect workforce availability, insurance costs and asset viability. AI may improve productivity while introducing new dependencies and cyber vulnerabilities.

There are opportunities, too. Organisations able to adapt to disruption, maintain delivery or provide alternatives may strengthen their competitive position. 

Do we know what the risk could cost?

The survey reveals a significant gap in reported activity between risks influencing decisions and the quantification of their potential financial impacts.

Cybersecurity and technology disruption had actively shaped decisions for 50.1% of respondents, yet only 21.9% had quantified the potential financial impact.

For geopolitical and geoeconomic risk, 29.7% reported it had shaped decisions, while just 13% had quantified the financial exposure.

Even for liquidity and funding risk, where financial quantification was most common, only 40.1% had quantified the potential financial impact.

Not every risk lends itself to a precise dollar figure. Nor should financial quantification become an exercise in manufacturing certainty.

Boards make decisions involving capital allocation, investment, insurance and risk appetite, often with incomplete information. Financial ranges and sensitivity analysis can help directors understand potential consequences and weigh trade-offs without creating false precision or delaying decisions in pursuit of certainty. 

AI is moving faster than the governance conversation

The survey found 75.9% had discussed generative AI use within their organisation, and 61.6% had discussed cyber risks amplified by AI-enabled threats.

Yet only 36.3% had discussed the financial or liability exposure arising from AI use.

AI is influencing how organisations work, the information they rely on and the decisions they make. Its risks extend beyond cyber incidents or inappropriate use of public AI tools.

Directors do not need to become technology specialists. They do, however, need sufficient understanding to challenge management, recognise material exposures and seek assurance that AI is being managed effectively, beyond the existence of policies.

Prepared for the next disruption, or the longer term?

The survey found 59.2% had discussed business continuity and disaster recovery, 43.8% had reviewed physical exposure of key assets or operations, and 39.6% had reviewed insurance coverage or affordability.

However, just 17% had undertaken scenario analysis or stress testing, and 18.8% had considered long-term adaptation or relocation.

The emphasis on business continuity is understandable. When disruption occurs, organisations need to protect people, restore operations and meet immediate obligations. But preparing to recover from an event is different from assessing whether existing assets, locations and operating models will remain viable as conditions change.

An insurance renewal may address the financial consequences of damage today without resolving questions about future affordability or insurability. A business continuity plan may help restore operations after flooding but may not answer whether the organisation should continue investing in the same location.

These are strategic questions about asset life, capital allocation and investment timing. Resilience needs to be considered while boards still have choices.

The danger of confusing process with preparedness

Formal risk practices are well established across much of the survey sample, with 63.4% reviewing enterprise risk quarterly or more frequently. Yet regular review does not necessarily mean an organisation is prepared.

A detailed risk register may offer reassurance while leaving important dependencies poorly understood. Quarterly reporting may be sufficient for some risks and too slow for others.

Responses also vary considerably by organisation size. Among respondents from organisations with revenue or budgets below $1 million, 51.5% selected none of the listed geopolitical risk actions, compared with 9% among organisations above $50 million.

This does not establish that smaller organisations are managing risk poorly. Their exposures, resources and available responses differ. However, it reinforces the importance of proportionate governance, access to appropriate advice and knowing when established practices are providing more comfort than insight.

From risk awareness to better choices

Better decisions may mean reducing exposure. Sometimes they involve accepting a risk because the potential benefits justify it. In other circumstances, they require changing an investment, building additional capacity or deciding an activity is no longer viable.

Effective oversight requires boards to understand how changing circumstances affect strategic assumptions, where risks intersect and what the consequences mean for the organisation. They also need to be clear about the organisation’s appetite for different types of risk, available options and what would warrant a different response.

Boards cannot eliminate uncertainty or expect perfect information about every possible future. Their responsibility is to exercise judgement, make deliberate choices and ensure the organisation can respond as circumstances change.

The value of risk oversight should be measured by the decisions it informs, rather than the risks it records. 

The Institute of Directors’ Risk Survey 2026 was conducted with support from Marsh and received 348 responses from directors and other governance and executive leaders. 

Explore these findings

Join our Risk Survey 2026 webinar on 3 December, where directors and risk experts will discuss how boards can challenge assumptions, test resilience and make informed decisions.